Slide Show
View Slide Show 19 Photographs

Credit James Nachtwey

Slide Show
View Slide Show 19 Photographs

Credit James Nachtwey

James Nachtwey Fights TB, With Pictures

James Nachtwey is known for his compelling images of human suffering. He has captured genocide, disease and starvation. Absorbing so much devastation through the lens would numb many photographers, but Mr. Nachtwey is undaunted.

“I try to stay open,” said Mr. Nachtwey, who is a contract photographer for Time and a contributor to National Geographic. “It has become only harder — not easier — to do. But I realize that if I don’t do it, then I won’t be as effective; my pictures won’t have the same depth and humanity.”

James Nachtwey Swaziland: A woman with multidrug-resistant TB is comforted by her mother.

When Mr. Nachtwey was awarded a TED Prize in 2007, receiving $100,000 to help fulfill “one wish to change the world,” he chose to tell a visual story about tuberculosis.

“This is about a disease that had been completely in the shadows,” Mr. Nachtwey said, allowing that he himself had once believed it was “more like an archaic disease that had virtually disappeared.”

He first encountered the ravages of TB when shooting an assignment on AIDS in Africa in 2004. Thereafter, he kept observing its devastating effects. Tuberculosis is the leading cause of death for people already suffering from failing immune systems due to AIDS. It has also mutated into deadlier strains known as multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) and, even worse, extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB).

A TB patient in SwazilandJames Nachtwey Swaziland: A patient receives an infusion in a home visit from missionaries.

In the hope of putting TB “on the radar screen,” Mr. Nachtwey traveled to seven countries that are struggling with the disease, working with nongovernmental organizations and public health officials.

“I wanted to do it through the lens of people actually being cured for TB or treated in some way, to show that there was care going on but it’s difficult,” he said.

At a hospital in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa, where an outbreak of extremely drug-resistant tuberculosis killed 52 of its 53 victims in 2005; at a Buddhist temple in Cambodia; and at a prison colony in Siberia, Mr. Nachtwey documented the suffering of those infected, the families watching over them and the health care workers trying desperately to combat the epidemic.

A TB patient in IndiaJames Nachtwey India: A patient in Mumbai, with advanced pulmonary TB, receives a daily injection and oxygen.

Focused on making the public aware of the global dimensions of the TB threat, Mr. Nachtwey said he hoped his images would spark new initiatives, further research and an increase in spending on the disease.

An exhibition of his photos, “Struggle to Live: The Fight Against TB,” is up until March 25 at 401 Projects, a gallery at 401 West Street in Manhattan.

The large black-and-white prints capture men and women whose bodies clearly show the contours of their skeletons, doctors in masks examining X-rays and administering shots to fearful patients, and children struggling to take their last breaths.

“You really have to open yourself and identify with the people you’re photographing and try and have a real emotional connection,” Mr. Nachtwey said. “Without that, if you don’t have the emotions yourself, you can’t translate those emotions to anyone else.”


Beginning Thursday, you will need to be a registered Times reader to comment on posts published on the Lens blog. Doing so is free.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

JN is the best,

James Nachtway “Fights TB With Pictures?” The arrogance of this guy is astonishing. Exactly how is violating the privacy of extremely ill people receiving medical care for purposes of shock value and self-aggrandizement fighting TB? I guess this comment will never see the light of day…

I can understand some viewers feeling that James Nachtway’s TB pictures are an invasion of privacy at peoples’ moment of greatest agony. I believe however that the overall value of these powerful images transcends the necessary transgression. Without images like this, much of the western world would remain insulated from the reality of life in impoverished regions. The west has the resources to fight and overcome problems like disease resistant TB and poverty but westerners need to see (and be bothered) other people’s suffering; otherwise we will simply remain content to live our comfortable pampered lives, indifferent to what’s really going on. This is an issue that can not be ignored. The threat of drug resistant TB will not remain somebody else’s problem for long.

Au contrare Mel , James Natchway’s efforts to make us aware of this illness brings to the light of day this hidden epidemic and makes vividly clear its impact on real people. There is nothing arrogant or invasive in bringing the suffering of humanity before our eyes. This is what makes the difference between art ,which awakens and touches something in us at a deep and empathetic human level , and tabloid sensationalism which exploits human suffering for a momentary thrill and profit. Natchways art unites us ,if for but a brief moment, in our shared humanity across this tiny planet.

Once again, an incredible body of work in dealing with another issue that most people would prefer to ignore. And in answer to “Mel”, I have found that suffering people actually are grateful that at least someone cares about their plight and maybe something will be done to improve their situation. This, while cynical people like Mel prefer to turn away.

So, if all of y’all are feeling united by our common humanity, then I assume you will help get the dollars flowing. Partners in Health works on this issue in Haiti and elsewhere. They do groundbreaking work and would be an excellent place to demonstrate our shared humanity with dollars.

I wish I had a way to track who among you decides to contribute. Somehow, I’m betting on Mel. Please let me know that I am wrong.

We know TB is a problem and a resurgent one, as well.

We do not need some shooter exploiting ill people unable to stop him from taking their pictures. I was a PJ and all I can tell you is that these celebrity PJ’s have big egos and they don’t care about these people beyond the picture. They care about their careers and fame. Get over yourself and let these people perish with a bit of dignity.

Pictures of people cured by aid organizations don’t really help the PJ career, do they? or they would be shooting that and asking you to give to support the good work and successes that these organizations achieve.

None of this work is unique beyond having a vehicle. “Every picture has already been taken” – that is a quote by a dean of the photography department at a very credible school. And he is right, because if you take your camera to any place where there is human suffering, you will come back with “a great body of work”. There will always be slight differences in a photo, but for the most part, it will be the same as pictures of people suffering 100 years ago. And suffering people “are always grateful”, because they don’t have the energy or confidence to swat a camera away. They suffer these indignities quietly in the hope that something, anything, will save them. They are the least able to be “ungrateful”. Give me a break from your progressive, perfect world.

Just as a fashion photographer has a hard time making a bad picture of a pretty girl wiggling in front of his camera, any photographer has a hard time shooting a “bad” picture of suffering humans.

We know suffering exists out there and a photo is not needed to prove that. This isn’t even art, just poor people suffering. Get over your fawning photographer groupie selves and just give money to a reputable aid organization that can serve these people with dignity. I am giving away all my money away and die a pauper for the greater good.

Photographers like Nachtwey and Salgado are following in the footsteps of people like Gene Smith and Jacob Riis. They are, as the French say, engagé. Engaged in the struggle for human rights and dignity in the hopes that illustrating these conditions will make the world aware of what it must do.
I am an agnostic but didn’t Jesus say “how you treat the least among you is how you treat me”?

As I thought. Nary a response when we are challenged to apply our personal funds to solving the problem so exquisitely captured by the photographer.

Aesthetics of suffering, anyone?

bleah.

For shame. Shame.

Picture 3 is like a contemporary Pietà.

If anybody is interested in the fight against TB across the world. Check out “Mountains Beyond Mountains” by Kidder. It talks about PIH’s efforts in Haiti, Peru, Boston, and Russia. It opened my eyes to TB and its effects on poorer nations. I always knew that TB was out there but this book and these photos put it in the forefront.

Correction, Clem; you know. I didn’t. And I’m pretty sure a whole lot of people around you and me don’t know either.

Everybody knows the holocaust took place, yet there’s more advertisement on the topic, not to mention memorial events now than ever before.
Everybody knows that breast cancer exists, yet, it’s all we hear all over the place.
I could go on.

To communicate is to remember.

If you want to donate your pocket money to organisations, go ahead. That can be seen as both noble and positive for you and your entourage, not to mention the ones you help.
But please, please, spare us the dreadful lectures.

I’d rather have someone like Nachtwey and his peers base their entire careers and lives, travelling the world and bringing back stories such as this one, endangering their own lives in the process and literally devoting themselves to their beliefs, in hopes that amidst all the talk, there will be action, than to read those posts of yours.

I encourage anyone in the New York area to go see these photos up close. They are incredibly powerful in the full presentation setting.

XDR-TB continues to ravage the most vulnerable populations in all of the countries where Mr. Nachtwey photographed these patients nearly 5 years ago. Within the last year, the first case of XDR-TB was reported in the United States. This issue pleads for immediate action, and I think James does an excellent job refocusing attention where it is desperately required.

To communicate is to remember:
Yes, very true, I agree with it.

but we also have to remind ourselves that
“to be remembered” for eternity comes with pain.

For example, Gene Smith’s centerpiece photo of Minamata, a mother cradling her deformed, naked daughter, Tomoko, has been withdrawn from circulation in accordance with Tomoko’s parents’ wishes since 1997.

You can check Gene Smith’s wife, Aileen’s statement on the decision here. very thought provoking.

The Photograph “Tomoko and Mother in the Bath”

Ok, I am now issuing a challenge.
For Haiti, I raised $1200 from my friends and myself for Partners in Health in one week.

All you photography appreciaters, advocates of communication, and appreciators of the aesthetics of suffering, perhaps you would like to match this?

Partners in Health
you can donate directly, report on your participation here. since we are all basically anonymous, no one will have a thing to say about how much you personally gave.
The amounts given by people I solicited ranged from $10 to $300 a pop.

You’d be amazed at how much this would help…

Oh, and Emily Jump? you wrote: “This issue pleads for immediate action, and I think James does an excellent job refocusing attention where it is desperately required.”

So who do you think will take action, if not us?

Nachtwey’s photos, as one commentator mentioned, are art. They are tragically beautiful. But they are also tragically missing in many elements. The subjects are nameless, skeletal receptacles to carry the photographers/NGOs message. They hark back to the ‘picturing of poverty’ from the past, not the future. We hear neither who they are or from them. Nor the health workers. The people pictured are prone, in pain (never a smile, even from someone recovering).We never see the ‘end result’ of treatment. The families. We are told of ‘catastrophe’ and ‘fathomless slums’ – this is Biblical, tapping into our pity and outrage. But the images create distance – the other – from dissected geographic realms of poverty we are protected from. This is not the only way to picture such subjects, this is not the only way to motivate people to take action – in fact, many would argue that this is no longer the best way – morally (informed consent on how the images will be used by the subjects – you don’t see the rich being photographed in their hospital beds) and strategically (compassion fatigue – though actually this should rather be termed ‘lack of solution fatigue).

Nice photos but time to go beyond that.

Rob Godden
The Rights Exposure Project

Robert Godden, thank you for this link and comment–I am really interested in this development.

And what do you think about the money issue?

Robert,

Perhaps your “.com” can get in touch with Nachtwey’s “.org”

Take Action

Albert

Albert,

If you read my “.com” you would see I work for a “.org”.

I take action every day.

Rob

Are those who are against Nachtwey and other photojournalists actually advocating that they stop documenting human suffering? And that will somehow make things better?

How would those of us who have the means to contribute otherwise be made aware of that suffering ? Average citizens in more affluent nations have an infinite number of distractions and bourgeois concerns that completely consume everyday consciousness. If it wasn’t for Nachtwey and others in his tradition, most of us would be oblivious.

While growing up I learned a lot about the state of the world — and things like suffering and courage — from the photographs of Eugene Smith and the Magnum photographers. I believe we should be thankful for people like James Nachtwey. To disparage this important work is to be willfully ignorant.

Thank you M. Nachtwey, for your work

Lucie mallette

Are you still alive?
I can’t see, but anyway, I want to thank You very much for your lifetime and Work. I use to talk about it to anyone I meet..
sister of Florian Eidenbenz, swiss-german sound engineer for films (e.g. War Photographer), doughter of a graphic designer and photographer, Hermann Eidenbenz in HamburgGermany,, Basel/ Zurich/ Switzerland

Albert and Robert, you are both right, but we need more encouregement, while so many people live still in blindness, and the money is spent in idiotical amusements ore childish timewasting occupations – that’s the choice of everyone.

nobody knoes how many time there will be left to ‘help’
whom
what for?
help to nature
or kids or climate??
Sorry for my indulgence, but sometimes I think we have left no time at all!
ARS LONGA VITA BREVIS

“mel” this shows how ignorant you are. you obviously have not ever seen any of his other work or read anything about him. he takes these pictures to get word out about the people and to help them. “I have been a witness, and these pictures are my testimony. The events I have recorded should not be forgotten and must not be repeated.”

-James Nachtwey-

Pictures of the Week

View all Pictures of the Week